DM: There's a moment of tense silence as the two of you lock eyes and size each other up.
Applejack: The imposter DID say somethin' about body doubles, but mah gut says that was jus' to sow paranoia.
Twilight Sparkle: I'm not too worried, but... I *slowly* let my magic fade out as I approach. How do I know you are the real Princess Cadance?
Princess Cadance: H-How do I know you're the real Twilight Sparkle?
(beat)
Twilight Sparkle: Crap. Good question.
This situation probably isn't helped by the fact that, out-of-character, this is technically the first time these two players are playing these two characters interacting. What a wonderfully intricate mess.
New Spudventures is up!
The Forgotten Ones, Session 26 - Crypts and Field Trips: Podcast | Video
Note: Guest comic submissions are now open! Guidelines here. Current deadline: 4/1/21.
Loving the expressions you chose. Also, I was just thinking that same thing you wrote in your author's note. They have to create a pre-existing bond out of thin air, while playing it out. Should be fun reading.
Hehe, this reminds me of something I ran a couple months back. We are playing on Discord voice chat, and the PCs got captured by the undead.
One of the PCs was dragged off to be questioned alone. I did this in a separate voice chat, leaving the other PCs to RP how they wished during this time. His interrogator just started asking him basic questions: his name, where he was from, who his companions were, starting to edge towards actual intelligence by the end. The PC mostly cooperated, figuring it would create more opportunities and that the information he was giving wasn't that actionable.
Then the interrogator turns outside the room and goes, "Did you get all of that?" and a Deathlock came out of the shadows and used Disguise Self to look like the PC after having studied him for several minutes. I then brought him *back* to the group playing the Deathlock, to confirm anything he said and to hopefully get more information. It was a great scene.
And this is why my sorcerer in one campaign, who’s very paranoid, has plans for the identity confirmation of the entire party as well as two or three important NPCs. It’s a simple 7-step process that she expects to happen without any prompting from her, so it’s really more 8 steps, but it includes “something only you would know” and “when did we first do *something they never did*”, alongside “who am I”, “do *something only they could do*”, “have you seen *one of the sorcerer’s secret identities that the party knows of* in the last few minutes”, and “when did I tell you *something she said two or three days ago*”. She won’t give any hints or anything so people are very confused and slip up.
One, having a character that can't remember a complicated speech, and being prompted to give it -- the imposter has too high of an opinion, gives the speech properly, and outs themselves. (See Naruto).
The other? The people are tossing out numbers. The trick? Don't say a number that has already been said, and the new imposter doesn't know the history or the rule.
There’s a bit of that too — she gives anything in *asterisks* just out of the blue and they’re expected to respond with all of the answers, so the person also has to know the protocol.
I'm kind of reminded of a Shadowrun game I've been playing off and on for a few years. A couple of adventures ago, we discovered that the BBEG is apparently a clone of my character.
The following adventure, we discovered that the BBEG might not be the one who's a clone.
Nick: Prove you're not a Skrull.
[Carol fires photon blast right past Nick's ear, after which Nick gives a look that says “what does that prove?!]
Carol: That's a photon blast.
Nick: And!?
Carol: A Skrull cannot do that.
While I know this line of thinking wasn't the intent, I can't help but see Twilight's response and think of the Ducktales reboot episode where Launchpad accidentally convinces himself he's actually a mole person infiltrating the surface.
New Spudventures is up!
The Forgotten Ones, Session 26 - Crypts and Field Trips: Podcast | Video