Twilight Sparkle: Well... Hmm. I guess I _could_ fight them and pull my punches, but...
Princess Cadance: ^Now there's a funny idea...^
Twilight Sparkle: If you've got a plan, I'm all for it.
Princess Cadance: Oh, I don't want to cut you off and stop you from doing something clever.
Twilight Sparkle: No no, I am totally clevered out. By all means.
Princess Cadance: Alright, well, these are just the hypnotized bridesmaids, right? They're still themselves deep down. And it just so happens that the impostor replaced me while I was picking out the bouquet, which I still have. What happens if I wave the bouquet in front of their faces and then throw it?
DM: They dive out of your way.
Minuette, Lyra Heartstrings, and Twinkleshine: I WANT IIIIIIT!
Twilight Sparkle: *OH!* I could–...! Ah, it's fine. We'll come back for them later.
When everyone brings a unique toolset to deal with a wide variety of problems, sometimes it's courteous to save your idea and let someone else go ahead with theirs so they can stay engaged and have fun. Unless that idea has a 15:1 ratio of problems caused for the party to problems solved. Then it might be time to step in.
Note: Guest comic submissions are now open! Guidelines here. Current deadline: 4/1/21.
Also, keep an eye on people who think everyone else's ideas are bad, and try to remind them to let others have their time in the spotlight, even if it's less efficient (as long as it's not unbearably dumb, as our good author reminds us). Doubly so if you catch yourself being the one who does that.
So, on the topic of Crazy Solutions to plans... Well, some people I know have learned enough history to the point that they:
1. Don't actually PLAN for a specific solution to any puzzles, they just put a Situation in front of the players and go "What do you do?"
2. They do NOT dismiss any plans out of hand for being 'Too Silly'
And one of the cited reasons is the historical Siege of Detroit in the War of 1812. For those unfamiliar, here's the basics:
A British force led by Major General Isaac Brock was allied with a Native American coalition under the Shawnee leader, Tecumseh. Between the two of them, they didn't have NEARLY enough troops to take the fort of Detroit.
However, Tecumseh said "Watch this". He then found a break in the trees that were visible from the fort, and took his troops. He then had his troops march conspicuously from one side of the break to the other, and then loop back around to rejoin the march. He had them do this for hours.
Meanwhile, within the fort, the forces led by Brigadier General William Hull saw what looked like a line of Native warriors marching for hours, and surrendered because they felt they didn't have enough troops to match such a massive force.
Which sounds like a plan put in a "Media Screencaps as a Tabletop Game" as a joke where the punchline is "Literally nobody is dumb enough to fall for that"
Cadence: Weren't those your friends from school?
Twilight: More like associates. Now, I've got a whole sheet full of battle magic memorized and noplace to use it. Shall we go to the wedding?
Cadence: Just as long as you don't fry Shining Armor.
Twilight: Meh, he's always known enough to duck.