Page 1674 - Roll for Initiation

7th Apr 2022, 6:00 AM in What About Discord?
<<First Latest>>
Roll for Initiation
Average Rating: 0 (0 votes)
<<First Latest>>

Author Notes:

Newbiespud 7th Apr 2022, 6:00 AM edit delete
Newbiespud
And somehow I've stumbled into a subtextual theme of reconciling the differences between casual and hardcore tabletop players. A subject I don't feel nearly qualified enough to weigh in on, but here we are.

Notice: Guest comic submissions are open! Guidelines here. Deadline: January 27th, 2023.

(Pop-out)

9 Comments:

Digo 7th Apr 2022, 6:53 AM edit delete reply
I don't miss my old days of hardcore gaming. I was always more about the story, even when I used to play as fighters with the big two-hander. I guess on that chart of "Real men, Real roleplayers, Loonies, & Munchkins" I'm in the second category. ^^
Prairie Son 7th Apr 2022, 7:47 AM edit delete reply
I never found any of those really fit me. Which may be part of the reason it's been so easy for me to leave the hobby for a few years repeatedly; I'm not invested enough in playing to develop a style.
aylatrigger 7th Apr 2022, 7:20 PM edit delete reply
I am Muchkin/Real Roleplayer/Loony, more the first two. I get ideas to roleplay usually by munchkinning characters, or I get a roleplay idea and then munchkin them. But I do roleplay them and backstory them up. Loony is a consequence of GMing a loony group for years and preferring pizazz to seriousness.
My last character was a Frankenstein's monster type 'Created' (from Skybourne) who was four heads on a torso. Used summoning to clad myself in summoner synthesist eidolon, plus had a cat-ooze mount. Cat-ooze was constantly drunk and made of jello shots. I gave all of them backstories and personalities, mostly let the leader-head do the talking, and played fairly seriously within the silly premise. Also *very* munchkinned premise, though not Tier 1. (I prefer lower tiers but munchkin to those...) Got a lot for being a four-headed paraplegic, and could even wield 4 lances at once. Other less silly characters were about same power level, so did not feel too bad about it.

..Even when I play Real Man type characters, which that kind of counted as (my role was mostly a charging lancer with a bit more utility and finesse), I never feel I am one though.
aylatrigger 7th Apr 2022, 7:38 PM edit delete reply
Also, glad to see someone mention those player types... I am working on a world with a pantheon based on some friends' gods ideas that I have realized each god basically fits one of those categories, but was a bit worried if the reference was too outdated :)

Elemental Gods trapped in a plane so only they are the gods for the people there, and they are forced to be on that material plane so generally take more center stage/have more effect than most pantheons.
Animus, LG human, god of Air, Light, Community, Recreational Drugs, and Assassins - Real Roleplayer
Aou'kun, CE platinum dragon, god of Earth, Light, Alcohol, War, Barfights - Real man
Chord, LE noble monitor lizard, goddess of Water, Darkness, Drow, Undead, Trade, War, ...Muscle Wizards, Time, Ice, the Moon, Dinosaurs and Sea Serpents...and a bunch more. - Munchkin
'The Nameless Godthing', CG some kind of eldritch horror, deity of Fire, Darkness, the Sun, Insanity, helping the weak, tentacles?, giving to the poor...basically combine Cthulhu and Robin Hood. - Loony.

And yes, since Sun/Darkness, the sun is a giant blacklight. ...Which if you stare at too long, you may go insane.

Though biggest effect I think gods have is Chord decided her 'traditional prayer' is a short request that obeys min requirements for her to get power from it plus a proportional tithe to her church for services rendered, proceeds going to fund making Decanters of Endless Water turned on and dumped into the ocean. Most of the world is ocean by now. The planet's original core was porous rock that oozes alcohol with many caves for bars, so eventually floated to the surface. ...Plants that grow there are all alcohol based, so people either worship Aou'kun to live off alcohol, trade prayer and money to Chord for 'vitafish' which contains all daily nutrients and medicine that you need, or live in the clouds where countries are closer to 'normal' except Animus will send assassins if they aren't ruled by LG people.
RuBoo 8th Apr 2022, 7:41 AM edit delete reply
…Which one am I if I tend to make characters based on video game characters? Noting that I’ve never actually played the game, I just like turning existing characters into D&D characters…
evileeyore 7th Apr 2022, 11:17 AM edit delete reply
evileeyore
Funny thing about "hardcore vs casual"... many casual are as hardcore about the RP and emotional connections/impacts as the 'hardcore' players/GMs are about the PvGM of 'hardcore'. To the extent it's turned friends of mine off of roleplaying, they call it "that game of funny voices and crying"., whereas I know if I could just get them into a game that more "old skool", they'd find it fun, it's the tactical/strategic aspect they'd enjoy, not the "funny voices" and "roleplaying" aspect.
Roguim 7th Apr 2022, 3:57 PM edit delete reply
Never was a true casual or hardcore player neither any of my groups, Some Rules' lawyer there and here but nothing that affect the game harmony..
Jennifer 8th Apr 2022, 4:32 PM edit delete reply
My game at work, which I will be starting up again this summer, is basically Free Kriegspiel, so the main rule is "The DM tells you what to roll." And if I don't think you need to roll, well then!
AnonponyDASHIE 9th Apr 2022, 1:54 PM edit delete reply
Honestly, I think that reconciling the difference between casual and hardcore players tends to be a rather common theme among most TTRPG groups. Very rarely will you find a group where everyone and the DM is on the same page and enjoys all the same aspects of the game, but it's still incredibly important to ensure that all players and the MD get to have a good time.

Everyone plays TTRPGs to have fun in some capacity, it's just that everyone finds different things fun, and a group that can incorporate everyone in that is a special thing indeed.